The Pen is mightier than the sword...
From both the title and the fact that I found the link in the Times' Tech & Web section (even though the article itself is in the Arts & Entertainment section), one might have assumed that some statistical research had been done, and that the conclusion would be that within ten years everyone would be reading e-books and electronic newspapers à la Minority Report, and that the printed work would wither away and die.
However, on actually reading the article the thrust was about the decline of the traditional bookshop, not the book per se. It is indeed true that the traditional high street bookshop has largely disappeared - in terms of being able to wander into a shop and browse for a book, all that remains are the chains such as Borders and Waterstones, which for the most part offer a diet of sensationalist Z-list "biographies" and chick lit. Then there are the supermarkets, which offer the same fare, with the addition of the morbid childhood trauma paperback that has become the fashionable read for bored housewives. The glut of such books seems to suggest that this sort of thing is commonplace, so much so that one can safely assume that the likes of Sharon Shoesmith don't shop at Tesco.
It is indeed a shame - nay, a travesty - that many of the traditional old bookshops have disappeared from view, and that those that remain are in facing a serious financial struggle to even survive. I remember very well the days before the Internet, when I would take a journey into London and march up and down the Charing Cross Road - there were many interesting and controversial political works to be found at a place called Al Hoda, there was Sportspages (mentioned in the article) where I would be able to get hold of obscure German-language football annuals.
Then of course there was Foyle's - the veritable grand old mother of all bookshops. With its distinctive 1930s era atmosphere, Foyle's was place where everything was happily higgledy-piggledy, an Aladdin's Cave where you could find anything from little books on expressing the present tense in Tagalog through to the richly-bound door-stop biographies on Waffen-SS Panzer divisions. Even the method of payment was wonderfully old-school: you'd select your book and hand it to an assistant sitting behind a desk, who would scribble out a hand-written receipt which you would then take to the cashier to process. It was like either stepping back in time.
Alas, this is no more. Desperate to keep up with its slicker neighbours such as Books Etc. and Borders, Foyle's went through a massive revamp: remarketed, rebadged, and reorganised. It even lost the apostrophe: Foyle's became Foyles. The dusty, almost library-like charm has long gone, as have the paper receipts. The books on offer are of the same ilk as their competitors, and not since the day it was rebranded was I able to find the military history titles I used to make the journey into London for. It's as if along with the remarketing the politically correct police had called by to tell the management they could no longer stock copies of Panzermeyer's autobiography Grenadier.
So yes, the traditional bookshop is disappearing from our high streets, but does this signal - as the title of the Times article suggests - the decline and fall of the book? Far from it. If anything, the likes of Amazon and eBay have increased our interest in all things printed. We are now able to find books we could never locate in the bookshops, and more besides. With online portals such as Alibris that connects online buyers with small booksellers around the world - one can pick up obscure, long-lost texts and even those books from childhood days. Book festivals like that held every year at Hay-on-Wye bring in armies of visitors from all around the world.
It is going to be a very long time until we, as human beings, determine that the printed word is dead as we leaf through our latest purchase on our Kindle e-reader. Blackwell's Espresso Book Machine may itself be a marvel of modern technology, but its very existence is proof of the fact that we'd rather hold a book and be able to physically leaf through its pages than perform this function with a sweep of an index finger across a touchpad or the click of a mouse.
Labels: Everyday Stuff









